• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Payne’s Pizza & More

At Payne’s Pizza & More, we believe that great food is about more than just taste; it’s about bringing friends and families together. Nestled in Delaware, Ohio, our restaurant offers a delightful array of pizzas, salads, and hearty sandwiches, all crafted with fresh ingredients. Our commitment to quality shines through in every dish, from our classic 8" pizzas to our comforting baked pasta options like lasagna and chicken parmesan. With convenient amenities including delivery, outdoor seating, and catering services, we aim to create a welcoming atmosphere for all. At Payne’s, we're not just serving food; we're creating memorable experiences.

Payne’s Pizza & More: Reviews & Ratings

Brian Tipton
Brian Tipton

New to the area and have tried a couple pizza shops. Paynes Pizza is the winner for us. The pizza was delicious, piping hot and full of flavor. Staff was friendly and attentive. If you have not ordered from them, you are missing out!

Brittany Johnson
Brittany Johnson

Today was my second time eating from there and the staff was awesome. Very attentive and the food is was fresh. Very good place.

Dee Hardison
Dee Hardison

Paynes food is always fantastic! The staff is always nice and our order is fast and correct!

Cindy Edmondson
Cindy Edmondson

Went there for an early dinner with my husband. We was just about done when one of the employees came in and was very loud with with another employee about how this employees didnt like him. Got pretty loud in the back with employees. ...

Jennifer Barrick
Jennifer Barrick

Good is always done correctly and on time. Tastes great as well. What more could you ask for?

Michael Waddell
Michael Waddell

A long time go to for our family. Pizza is solid, bakedSpaghetti is awesome, the grinders are awesome. and the macaroni salad is amazing! Customer service is also always topnotch and they are a big community supporter!

Brandi Carrino
Brandi Carrino

Really delicious! Kind staff. Wish the Paynes in my town of Marion also did a buffet, worth the drive everytime

Nathan Shireman
Nathan Shireman

I havent had Paynes in awhile but Im glad that I recently found them again. Really friendly team. I placed a togo order on the phone and they told me about the specials and made recommendations. The pizza was good, too.

Location

Welcome to my latest food adventure as I dive into the delightful offerings of Payne’s Pizza & More, a gem nestled in the heart of Delaware, Ohio. Known for their vibrant atmosphere and extensive menu, this establishment is not just a place to eat; it’s a community hub where families and friends gather to enjoy delicious food.

Payne’s Pizza & More specializes in a variety of dishes that cater to all tastes. Whether you’re craving a classic pizza, fresh salads, or hearty sandwiches, this eatery has something for everyone. Their pizza selection is particularly impressive, featuring sizes from an 8" personal pie at just $7.49 to a 16" large pizza for $18.74. Each option promises a delightful burst of flavors, crafted from high-quality ingredients.

Highlights of the Menu:

  • Pizzas: Choose from an array of sizes and toppings, perfect for sharing or for a solo indulgence.
  • Baked Pasta: This section is a must-try, featuring comfort food classics like thick, flavorful lasagna and chicken parmesan.
  • Appetizers: Start your meal with crispy garlic bread or savory chicken strips to whet your appetite.

One of the standout features of Payne’s Pizza & More is its welcoming atmosphere. The moderate noise level makes it suitable for groups, and the outdoor seating option enhances the dining experience, especially during pleasant weather. Additionally, the restaurant offers free Wi-Fi, making it a great spot for casual business meetings or a laid-back family outing.

For those on the go, Payne’s Pizza & More provides convenient delivery and takeout services, ensuring you can enjoy their delicious offerings from the comfort of your own home. They also cater to events, making it easier to share their culinary delights with friends at gatherings.

Speaking of convenience, with on-site parking and bike parking available, you can easily drop in—whether you're commuting by car or looking to pedal over for a meal.

All in all, my experience at Payne’s Pizza & More was nothing short of delightful. The warmth of the staff combined with the mouth-watering food creates an inviting environment that leaves you wanting more. So, if you find yourself in Delaware, Ohio, do yourself a favor and swing by to discover your new favorite pizza place!

For more information or to place an order, you can reach them at (740) 363-9040 or visit them at 400 W Central Ave, Delaware, OH 43015.